What Happens at a Suffolk County DWI Arraignment

An arraignment is the first court appearance after a person is charged. It is not the trial. The court tells the person what the charge is, addresses the right to a lawyer, and decides the next steps, including, in many DWI cases, what happens to the driver’s license.

People arrested in Suffolk County may be held after the arrest and brought to court for arraignment, or they may be released with an appearance ticket that sets a later date. The papers you were given will say when and where to appear. Bring those papers, including any license or temporary driving document, with you.

Where arraignments are held in Suffolk County

Many cases arising in the five western towns — Babylon, Brookhaven, Huntington, Islip, and Smithtown — are heard in Suffolk County District Court at the John P. Cohalan, Jr. Court Complex, 400 Carleton Avenue, Central Islip. Jordan M. Endler, Esq., practices in Islandia, in the Town of Islip, near that courthouse.

Arrests in the five eastern towns — East Hampton, Riverhead, Shelter Island, Southampton, and Southold — are often first heard in the town justice court named on the ticket. The ticket, not a general rule of thumb, is the document to follow.

What the court covers at the first appearance

The defendant has the right to the aid of counsel at the arraignment and at every later stage of the case. If the person appears without a lawyer, the court must advise of the right to an adjournment to obtain counsel, the right to communicate free of charge to arrange counsel or to notify a relative or friend, and, except on a charge that is only a traffic infraction, the right to have counsel assigned if the person is financially unable to hire a lawyer.

The court also explains the charge. Where a misdemeanor relating to traffic is charged, the court must warn that a conviction can affect the driver’s license and registration, and that a guilty plea is a conviction just as a verdict after trial would be.

A not-guilty plea is often entered at this first appearance so the case can proceed. The arraignment is the start of the case, not the day the facts are tried.

The license: New York’s prompt suspension law

Separate from any later sentence, New York law requires the court, in specified cases, to suspend a driver’s license pending prosecution. That suspension, often called a prompt suspension, generally applies when a person is charged with driving while intoxicated, aggravated driving while intoxicated, or driving while ability impaired by the combined influence of drugs and alcohol, and is alleged to have had a blood-alcohol concentration of .08 percent or more, as shown by a chemical test of blood, breath, urine, or saliva.

The suspension is supposed to occur no later than the conclusion of the arraignment. If the test results are not yet available, the court may impose the suspension later, once the results are received. Before suspending the license, the court must find that the accusatory instrument meets the legal-sufficiency requirements of the Criminal Procedure Law and that there is reasonable cause to believe the person drove with a BAC of .08 or more. The license holder is entitled to make a statement on those issues and to present evidence tending to rebut the court’s findings.

Other pending-prosecution suspensions can apply in different circumstances, including a prior alcohol- or drug-related driving conviction within the preceding five years, or a related felony charge involving injury or death. A chemical-test refusal is handled under a separate Vehicle and Traffic Law provision and can affect the license even when there is no test result. Driving while ability impaired by alcohol, standing alone, does not trigger the .08 prompt-suspension rule for an ordinary adult license.

Hardship privileges and later conditional licenses

A prompt suspension is still issued even if driving is needed for work. If the court finds that the suspension will result in “extreme hardship,” it may grant a limited hardship privilege. Extreme hardship means the inability to obtain another way to travel to or from work, to or from necessary medical treatment for the licensee or a household member, or, for a matriculating student at an accredited school, college, or university, to or from that school when the travel is necessary to complete the degree or certificate.

The burden of proving extreme hardship is on the licensee. A finding may not be based solely on the licensee’s own testimony, so pay stubs, a letter from an employer, medical appointment records, or a class schedule can matter. The court may not delay the arraignment more than three business days solely to allow that proof to be presented. A hardship privilege, if granted, is limited to those travel purposes and is not valid for a commercial motor vehicle. It is not automatic.

If a prompt suspension has been in effect for thirty days, the holder may be issued a conditional license under the Impaired Driver Program, if otherwise eligible. That license, too, is not valid for a commercial motor vehicle, and eligibility depends on the person’s record and current Department of Motor Vehicles rules.

Release pending the next court date

At arraignment the court also issues a securing order — the decision about release while the case is pending. For many first-offense misdemeanor DWI charges, monetary bail is not authorized. The court is generally required to release the person on their own recognizance, unless it finds that doing so will not reasonably assure the person’s return to court. In that event, the court may impose non-monetary conditions.

A felony charge, a prior record, or certain other accompanying charges can lead to a different result, including, in some cases, bail. Nothing in this article is a promise of release or of any particular license outcome.

After the arraignment, the case is typically adjourned to a later conference date. That is when negotiations, motions, and, if necessary, trial preparation continue.

If you have a Suffolk County court date, or you were arrested and have not yet been arraigned, call Jordan M. Endler, P.C. in Islandia at (631) 896-2211, or email Endlerlaw@gmail.com. He takes calls in the evenings and on weekends. Bring the papers you were given.

This article is general information about New York law, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Previous
Previous

A New York Power of Attorney: What It Does and Why It Matters

Next
Next

What Is Probate, and Why Do People Try to Avoid It?